Boynton Beach rejected all 12 bids to rebuild Pence Park, which came in 51% to 102% over the $4.4 million estimate. The city will seek proposals instead.
Updated Nov. 6: The City Commission approved both consent agendas, which included Resolution R26-208, by voice vote Thursday with no items pulled for discussion, according to the city’s video of the meeting. All 12 bids are rejected, and the city will seek proposals. No new timeline or funding source was given at the meeting.
Boynton Beach staff want to throw out every bid to rebuild Pence Park and start again. All 12 bids came in well over the city’s $4.4 million estimate. The lowest was $6,636,651.89 and the highest $8,872,525.
The City Commission votes on the plan Thursday. It is item 7.F, Resolution R26-208, on the consent agenda for the Nov. 5 meeting.
What the new park was to include
Pence Park is at 600 SE Fourth St. The project is a complete renovation and expansion. The staff report lists:
- demolition, site work and right-of-way improvements
- a synthetic turf multipurpose field with lighting and bleachers
- four pickleball courts
- a new main building
- a maintenance and storage building
- a playground with a shade structure
- parking
Why staff say the bids cannot be used
The city advertised the job on June 3 as a price-only invitation to bid. It issued eight addenda, pushed the due date back three times and opened the bids July 24. On Oct. 14 staff issued a notice that they intended to recommend an award. A closer review of the three lowest bids then turned up problems, the report said.
Staff give four reasons for rejecting them all:
- Every bid is over budget. Each one is 51% to 102% above the $4.4 million estimate, and any award “would require additional funding.”
- The drawings did not match the changes. Addenda issued July 13 and 15 revised the main building floor plan, the field, the pickleball court slab, the demolition limits and the site plan. The revised drawings “did not consistently reflect the changes the addenda described.”
- The prices are not comparable. On 24 of 50 line items, prices varied by more than two to one between bidders. The building trades were closely grouped; the site work was not.
- The rules changed days before bids closed. Addenda issued July 21 and 22 allowed alternate products, including playground equipment, so bidders may have priced different products.
The report said the recommendation “is not based on any determination regarding any individual bidder.”
What happens next
If the commission agrees, the city will seek proposals judged on price and other factors, which Florida law allows. Before it does, staff said:
- the architect will deliver a corrected, coordinated set of drawings with a revision log
- the architect will produce a current cost estimate
- the pricing form will carry unit prices for the site work that varied most
- staff will “identify funding for the project” before bringing a contract back to the commission
Proposals could be scored on price, qualifications, experience on similar public projects, approach and schedule, the report said. It gave no new timeline.
Also on Thursday’s agenda
- Jerry Taylor Avenue. Resolution R26-209 would add the honorary name “Jerry Taylor Avenue” to SE First Avenue between Seacrest Boulevard and SE First Street, beside City Hall and the library. Taylor served five terms as mayor. The official street name and addresses would not change.
- Holiday patrols. The Police Department wants to apply for a $20,709 federal Justice Assistance Grant to pay for overtime patrols at shopping centers over the holidays.
- Roadside landscaping. A two-year contract with East Coast Industries Corp. for right-of-way landscape maintenance, up to $700,721.22 a year.
- Second readings of the ordinances on factory-built and mobile homes and on a purchasing preference for veteran-owned businesses.
- Two economic development awards. The city’s Economic Development Division will mark a silver and a bronze 2026 award from the International Economic Development Council.
What it means for you
- Pence Park will not be rebuilt on the schedule the first bids implied. No new start date has been set. For other parks, see our parks and trails guide.
- You can speak on it. The meeting starts at 6 p.m. Thursday, Nov. 5, in the City Hall commission chambers at 100 E. Ocean Ave. Consent items are voted on as a group unless a commissioner pulls one for discussion. Public audience comments are limited to three minutes.
- You can watch online on the city’s commission meetings page. For help before the meeting, the City Clerk’s Office is at 561-742-6060.
Have your say